Your daily dose of Austin
Smartphone image
Make your inbox more Austin.
Local news and fun, every day 6am.
UT students, alumni debate 'The Eyes of Texas' amid national reckoning over race and cancel culture
(Stephen Spillman/CapitolPressPhoto)

Longhorns fans sing 'The Eyes of Texas' on Nov. 9, 2019.

More than a century after "The Eyes of Texas" was written, Natalie Wright entered the University of Texas for her freshman year.

The 2014 graduate was in the band, where she played the French horn.

"It was probably the formative part of my college experience," she told Austonia.

At the time, Wright felt the school song was a classic, one that transcended generations. "When I played it, I felt like I was part of something bigger than myself," she said.

But over the summer, like many others, Wright learned more about its origins, which include taking inspiration from a Robert E. Lee quote and first being performed at a minstrel show, where white performers wore blackface and mimicked Black Americans.

Members of a private Longhorn alumni band Facebook group are engaged in heated discussions over the song and its future, Wright said, and are divided largely along generational lines.

There are also students who support keeping "The Eyes of Texas" as the school song.

Longhorn quarterback Sam Ehlinger, who posted in support of the Black Lives Matter movement in May, defended the song in a post-game press conference on Oct. 12.

"I grew up singing 'The Eyes of Texas' win, lose or draw," Longhorn quarterback Sam Ehlinger said at a post-game press conference on Oct. 12. "I shared that experience with my (late) dad, and never once singing that song has anything negative ever crossed my mind."

But Dr. Stefan Bradley, a professor of African American Studies at Loyola Marymount University, said this dynamic fits into a long history of campus debates, over issues such as integration and going coed.

"It will be interesting to see how this ends," he said. "But I wouldn't be surprised if young people have their way with this."

Wright would be happy with such an outcome.

"In my opinion the younger generation just keeps carrying this torch of education and awareness and antiracism," she said. "I'm really impressed with how the kids younger than me are handling things like this."

Uncovered history

The killing of George Floyd at the hands of Minneapolis police on May 25 set off a national outcry over racism in America.

Students at UT-Austin—around 5% of whom are Black, compared to nearly 13% of the state's population—and on campuses across the country started petitions and lobbied for the removal of statues that commemorated Confederate leaders and slave owners.

In June, UT student-athletes asked the administration to take a series of actions, including renaming buildings such as the Robert Lee Moore Hall and replacing "The Eyes of Texas" with a song "without racist undertones."

The song's lyrics are not explicitly racist:

The Eyes of Texas are upon you,

All the livelong day.

The Eyes of Texas are upon you,

You cannot get away.

Do not think you can escape them

At night or early in the morn.

The Eyes of Texas are upon you

'Til Gabriel blows his horn.

But as Dr. Edmund T. Gordon, an associate professor of African and African diaspora studies and vice provost for diversity at UT-Austin, explains in his racial geography campus tour, the lyrics are drawn from a quote often repeated by the supreme commander of the Confederate army, Robert E. Lee: The eyes of the south are upon you.

The next month, University President Jay Hartzell responded with a letter, entitled "A More Diverse and Welcoming Campus." Although the university announced it would fulfill some of the students' requests—and has since taken steps to do so—the administration decided to keep "The Eyes of Texas" as the school song.

"It is my belief that we can effectively reclaim and redefine what this song stands for by first owning and acknowledging its history in a way that is open and transparent," Hartzell wrote.

On the field

Then the football season started.

Ehlinger, who posted in support of the Black Lives Matter movement in May, received press attention for being one of few players to sing the song after the Texas vs. Oklahoma game on Oct. 10. Although Ehlinger called the episode a "misunderstanding," it prompted the creation of a hashtag—#StandWithSam.

A group of disappointed alumni and fans of UT, who have not publicly identified themselves, launched a petition: #StandWithSam & The Eyes of Texas. It has received more than 16,000 signatures.

On Oct. 21, three days before the band's first live performance of the football season and in the middle of the campus celebration of Free Speech Week, The Daily Texan student newspaper broke news. The Longhorn band lacked the "necessary instrumentation" to play the school song at the Oct. 24 game against Baylor University.

Hartzell said there were no plans for the band to perform live at the Baylor game and said he "remain(s) truly optimistic that we will find ways to join together around our song, which has been so positive for so many Longhorns over the past 120 years," in an Oct. 21 statement.

The next day, the University of Texas System Board of Regents announced it's "unequivocally and unanimously in support of" Hartzell.

A campus tradition

Some students and alumni feel the song is a unifier that is being unfairly painted as a divider.

"I believe the anthem should remain," Jason Hannah wrote as his reason for signing the #StandWithSam petition. "Please don't allow the plague of cancel culture to destroy our history."

Others raised concerns that replacing the song would affect alumni giving to UT, which has the second largest endowment in the country, and disputed that the song was racist.

"There are no words in the 'Eyes of Texas' that should divide us," Jan Brown wrote. On Saturday, ahead of the Texas vs. Baylor game, a banner was flown around the Darrel K. Royal-Texas Memorial Stadium that directed people to the #StandWithSam petition homepage.

West Campus bar Cain and Abel's also hosted a pregame event celebrating the song, which it called "one of UT's greatest traditions" on its Facebook page.

Past precedent.

Bradley, the Loyola Marymount professor, said this type of debate is par for the course.

"What ends up happening is everybody has their vision of what their university was and is," he told Austonia. "The problem is that not everybody's vision matches.

Bradley's research focuses on Black student activism during the post-WWII era, including during the Civil Rights and anti-Vietnam War movements. During these periods, some alumni and university administrators pushed back against Black student activists and others advocating for policy changes, such the creation of an African American studies department or admitting women, arguing that doing so would compromise the university's standing.

Of course, now such changes seem inevitable.

With the debate over "The Eyes of Texas," students are similarly responding to cultural shifts—such as the Black Lives Matter movement—outside of the academy's walls, which are harder for the administration to control.

"The major stakeholders at the university … the students themselves believe that the university should operate a certain kind of way, and they've begun to operate in the way that they think the university ought to," he said. "That is very, very difficult to stop."

Bradley also responded to concerns about alumni giving, saying that there may be a cost associated with defending the song when it comes to young alumni and prospective students, who have grown up watching the media coverage of Trayvon Marton's death and live streamed video of Floyd's.

"No university wants to be known as the university that's mired in racial tensions," he said. "You can't sell that on the admissions tour."


Kaitlin Armstrong, suspect in Moriah Wilson murder, captured in Costa Rica after more than a month on the run

(U.S. Marshals)

The Austin woman suspected of killing star cyclist visiting from out of town, Moriah "Mo" Wilson, has now been captured after evading arrest for more than a month.

Keep ReadingShow less
As the EPA faces limits on greenhouse gas regulations, Texas researchers work on carbon capture tech

UT is developing technology targeted at power, steel, cement and other industrial plants to lower emissions. (UT Austin)

On Thursday, the Supreme Court limited the Environmental Protection Agency’s authority in regulating greenhouse gases, a move that comes at a time when experts have warned about the need to take action on climate change.

Keep ReadingShow less